ETHIvsVESG
Two different approaches to ethical investing. Which screens better?
BetaShares Global Sustainability Leaders ETF · Vanguard Ethically Conscious Intl Shares Index ETF
ETHI uses strict ESG screening - no fossil fuels, weapons, gambling or tobacco - and tilts toward global ESG leaders. VESG applies lighter filters across ASX stocks at a lower fee. ETHI is more exclusionary; VESG includes companies that stricter screens would eliminate.
Score Breakdown
Fund Profiles
BetaShares Global Sustainability Leaders ETF tracks the Nasdaq Future Global Sustainability Leaders Index, applying strict ESG screening to roughly 100 global companies. The methodology excludes firms involved in fossil fuels, weapons manufacturing, gambling, tobacco, and animal testing, creating a concentrated portfolio of companies meeting rigorous sustainability criteria. Suited to values-aligned investors who refuse to compromise on ethical standards, ETHI offers a responsible alternative to traditional global equity ETFs without sacrificing large-cap quality exposure.
Vanguard manages VESG, an ASX-listed ETF applying environmental, social, and governance screens to Australian equities drawn from the S&P/ASX 300 Index. The fund excludes fossil fuel producers and companies involved in controversial weapons, though its ESG filter is generally lighter than more aggressive ethical ETFs, retaining a broader investable universe closer to the mainstream index. Investors who want core Australian equity exposure with basic responsible investment exclusions - without straying too far from benchmark returns - will find VESG a balanced approach to ESG-conscious investing.